Top 10 Movies: Mystery

The highest-graded mystery movies we have reviewed, best first.

  1. Se7en1995Rain, rot and a box: Fincher's procedural commits to its nihilism and never blinks at the end.Read the review
  2. The Prestige2006Nolan structures the film as the trick it describes, and the prestige lands every time.
  3. The Usual Suspects1995A magic trick with a bulletin board, and knowing the ending only makes the construction more impressive.
  4. The Hateful Eight2015Tarantino locks eight liars in one room and shoots it like a landscape.
  5. Oldboy2003A revenge tragedy that turns the knife on the avenger, and on the audience.
  6. Harakiri1962A revenge film built as a legal argument, and the verdict destroys an entire code.
  7. The Third Man1949Carol Reed's tilted, rubble-strewn Vienna is the most atmospheric city in film noir, set to a zither tune that went to number one.
  8. The Secret in Their Eyes (2009)2009Campanella braids a cold murder case, an unspoken love and Argentina's debt to its dead into a crowd-pleaser with real teeth.
  9. Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban2004Cuaron throws out the tour guide and shoots the series like an actual film.
  10. Psycho1960Hitchcock murders his own star at the halfway mark and dares you to keep watching.

More lists

Every Top 10
  1. The critic's Top 10No. 1: The Shawshank Redemption
  2. DramaNo. 1: The Shawshank Redemption
  3. ActionNo. 1: Django Unchained
  4. ComedyNo. 1: The Hangover
  5. ThrillersNo. 1: Pulp Fiction
  6. Sci-FiNo. 1: Interstellar
  7. CrimeNo. 1: The Shawshank Redemption
  8. FantasyNo. 1: The Odyssey
  9. SuperheroNo. 1: The Dark Knight
  10. RomanceNo. 1: Forrest Gump