Best Games of 2004

Ranked by our critic's grades, best first.

  1. Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater2004A Cold War tragedy disguised as a survival sneaker, with the series' best bosses and its most complete ending.Read the review
  2. Halo 22004The game that invented online console multiplayer as we know it, with a campaign twice as bold as its predecessor.
  3. Half-Life 22004Physics, facial animation, and environmental storytelling promoted from decoration to core systems.
  4. Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas2004Three cities, a full RPG stat system, and the series' best script, somehow running on a PS2.
  5. Fable2004Smaller than the legend Molyneux promised, better than the backlash remembers.
  6. Dragon Quest VIII: Journey of the Cursed King2004The series stepping into three dimensions and finding the warmest, most confident version of itself.
  7. Ratchet & Clank: Up Your Arsenal2004The best arsenal the series ever assembled, in the year Insomniac also shipped competent online multiplayer on a PlayStation 2.
  8. World of Warcraft2004It won the genre by deleting the friction everyone else had mistaken for the point.
  9. Burnout 3: Takedown2004Criterion made crashing the point instead of the punishment, and no arcade racer since has felt this dangerous.
  10. Jak 32004The most generous entry in the trilogy and the one least certain about what it wants to be.