Top 10: Albums of All Time

The ten albums we would hand anyone asking where to start: all ten graded S, rap in the lead, and the rock records nobody sensible argues with.

  1. My Beautiful Dark Twisted FantasyKanye West · 2010Maximalism as a moral argument: every excess on the record is also its subject, and it never once buckles.Read the review
  2. good kid, m.A.A.d cityKendrick Lamar · 2012A short film about a teenager, a van and one very bad night, and the best constructed rap album of its decade.
  3. RevolverThe Beatles · 1966Fourteen songs, no two alike, none of them longer than they need to be. The best thing they ever made.
  4. The Dark Side of the MoonPink Floyd · 1973Forty three minutes on money, time, madness and death that plays like one continuous piece and never sags.
  5. The DocumentaryThe Game · 2005More than half a million copies in its first week and the West Coast back in the national argument.
  6. GraduationKanye West · 2007He swapped the soul loops for stadium synths and won the argument about where rap was headed.
  7. RumoursFleetwood Mac · 1977Five people falling apart in the same room, making the most listenable album of the decade about it.
  8. PiñataFreddie Gibbs and Madlib · 2014Gangster rap over dusty soul loops, and one of the great pairings of a rapper and a producer in any era.
  9. NevermindNirvana · 1991Punk songs given a radio mix so loud and so clean that they ate the culture within six months.
  10. 21Adele · 2011A breakup album written and sung so well that it stopped being a record and became furniture in millions of houses.

More lists

Every Top 10
  1. The critic's Top 10No. 1: My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy
  2. Rap AlbumsNo. 1: good kid, m.A.A.d city
  3. Rap DiscographiesNo. 1: Kanye West