Harsh Times Review
2005David AyerMovie
Bale is fully alive inside a film that mistakes repetition for portraiture.
| Category | Critic | Users |
|---|---|---|
| Plot | Weak | |
| Cinematography | Average | |
| Acting | Good | |
| Dialogue | Average | |
| Overall | Average |
David Ayer wrote Training Day and then directed this, and the resemblance is close enough to hurt. Jim Davis is a Gulf War veteran drifting around South Central with his friend Mike, drinking, shooting at things, waiting on a Homeland Security job, and for about forty minutes the aimlessness carries a documentary charge. Christian Bale is good, working a flat Southern California accent and a grin that arrives half a second before the violence. Freddy Rodriguez plays the friend as a man who keeps choosing the wrong afternoon.
But the script has one idea and repeats it until the wheels come off: Jim behaves badly, Mike enables him, Eva Longoria's Sylvia despairs, then the loop restarts. The nightmare flashbacks are the crudest available shorthand for trauma. The photography is slack, mostly flat daylight with none of the grain or menace the material wants. When the ending finally commits to bloodshed it feels less like a conclusion than like a writer running out of scenes. Bale is stranded, giving a committed and specific performance inside a film that has no idea what it thinks about him.
Harsh Times at a glance
- Director
- David Ayer
- Runtime
- 116 min
- Rating
- R
- Release year
- 2005
What’s your grade?
Grade by category
No account needed. Sign in so your grades follow you and count once. · how vote integrity works
Comments
Plain text, 500 characters. Be sharp, not cruel.
No comments yet. Have the first take.